Can’t force a horse to drink!

On July 25, 2010, in India, by

A friend wrote to me suggesting, among other things, that "if we want to become super power, we shall have to create things that are unique, and not restrict ourselevs to what is already used or implemented. Copying something already done we can not become leaders.. to become leaders we will have create something of our own.."

That set me off. I thought that's information worth publishing on my blog. I have had very similar debates with so many others. It seems Indians have a mania to try to prove that they are different from others. I totally disagree.,

Because all humans are exactly the same, within, my proposals all require very minor change from current systems in India to achieve wonderful results. In particular, I always recommend that a detailed understanding of human incentives should inform the design of governance structures. To the extent that we can incorporate natural human tendencies (desire to avoid accountability, lack of effort, arrogance, not consulting others, etc.), we'd have created something of interest. We basically need to ensure that bad people don't hijack such structures? Failure to do that dooms all 'systems' to failure. 

And yes, everything that works in the West can (and indeed has!) worked beautifully in India. Indians have the same DNA as any other human being. That proves the point. That is why they perform so beautifully in the West – because it rewards excellence and punishes bad performance. In India we do the opposite. That is not a creative 'solution'  but destruction. 

I don't believe that to reach the moon you have to reinvent physics within India. That would be an outrageous waste of time. So also for social performance and economic prosperity. I am 100% committed to world-best practice reforms, and don't care for where a good thing is invented. My books are my message. I distill the best from the world and offer these ideas to India. That's my goal. Whether Indians take it or use it is not my business. That's their problem! I can't force a horse to drink.


If you found this post useful, then consider subscribing to my blog by email:

Breaking Free of Nehru

Join the Freedom Team of India or become a Freedom Partner.

email
Google
Print Friendly
Tagged with:
 

2 Responses to “Can’t force a horse to drink!”

  1. While it's true that human nature is basically the same, we sometimes develop different methods of expressing the same needs. And in some places, certain needs are encouraged to grow and in others, it's so skillfully suppressed that you sometimes think it's not there at all!
    Also, people's mindsets are also shaped by their environment. This doesn't mean that their basic nature has changed. For example, people in the US enjoy living far away from the "hussle and bussle" of the city. The expensive properties in the suburbs are places where you sometimes have to drive for half an hour or more just to get a toothpaste in the local supermarket.
    In India on the other hand, we have kirana stores which are never more than a few minutes walk away from where we stay. As an India, I find it very difficult to live in the US (especially since I have an intense dislike for all cars) and love India where I can just cycle around. An American on the other hand, will hate living in India in the "middle of it all."
    The point I'm making is that certain solutions are appropriate to certain countries based on considerations like the ones give above. The US is much much larger than India and so solutions like urban sprawl make sense (though it's also wasteful – but that's another story.) In India, those solutions won't work. The public transportation system in the US is laughable, and yet they manage OK. But in India, we need public transportation much more than we need cars.

  2. Dear Bhagwat,

    The solution I recommend is NOT any cut and paste of any other country's solutions, but local solutions. Local preferences are crucial. Pl. read the section on local government in Breaking Free of Nehru (http://bfn.sabhlokcity.com/). India's tragedy is that central planners – bureaucrats – impose their will on India, not the local people.

    Regards

    Sanjeev 

Leave a Reply

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.



p-4j9aGt2RSyXeB